Sunday, October 19, 2014

Ink Blots

Looking out of my window and up at the sky has really become part of my daily routine. This week I noticed something quite odd. My seven year old nephew, Alex, joined me on one of my observation nights. At 7:05 pm we were debating on the shape of a certain cloud. Alex said that the cloud was in the shape of a duck while I said it looked like a rabbit and because he is a stubborn child he brought his younger brother Aiden, who is four, and his mom, Jeannette, who is twenty seven. Aiden just said the cloud looked like a circle and Jeannette said it looked like a sideways bird. After this conversation I realized how similar this situation was to a psychological test. I know that sounds really weird but in the Rorschach test, recognizing shapes in an ink blot is a way to evaluate your psychological health.


"Seeing radically different things than the typical responses or claiming to see nothing at all will definitely be held against you in terms of Rorschach scoring, and may result in a finding of "retardation" or a possible mental disorder. Seeing lots of different things in the card may also be taken as a sign of cognitive problems or even schizophrenia."


This test is used in the context of a custody case or evaluation. Although, some people part of the American Psychological Association do not agree with this method because of its unproven validity. Basically, there is no evidence of this test being effective or not. 
This test could be (or already is) unreliable if the real inkblot images were given to the public. Therefore, the ink blots in online tests or games are not the real thing. If you do know about the test (well you kind of do now because you're reading this) and you are going to be tested, it's recommended to tell the procter because your knowledge can affect your results. Below is an example of an Ink Blot.

"This is a card with black and red ink, often described as people dancing or touching hands with each other."



I wonder if the shapes we see in the clouds are similar to this test. I promise to research this another time. Could age just complicate the way we see things? Aiden is only four and could only attach his concept of the cloud to his small set of shapes he has seen. His cognitive thinking hasn't fully developed yet while Alex has a larger set of shapes and so his image was a bit more complicated even though he is still really young. Jeannette and I had even crazier ideas but the age gap between all of us are ranged and could prove this theory true. The Rorschach test is just a complex way of learning about someone. If you'd like to take a test yourself there are some links here and here.  Remember that this is not the real thing even if some of the pictures can be really similar. You do not have to believe any results you may have gotten. None of these tests are diagnosing you. If you really do believe you have a problem please contact a professional. Do not self-diagnose. 

(Edit: I just checked the tests and they were really inappropriate so I took them down. I'd rather not let students take really weird online tests that just insults you the entire time (they're probably trolls that changed the sites answers and choices). If you get curious and take one online please read the above statement again.)

8 comments:

  1. Great blog--even in your editing of the sites. Is it weird that I Santa looking in a mirror in the image you provided? It definitely seems that our age and experiences would affect what we see.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. I don't think that's weird. Now that I look at it, I see Santa too.

      Delete
  2. The connection was really cool. The way you showed the age differences and that effecting what they saw. What did you see in the picture? I see a face that is blurred out and under stress.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like how you got many different views on the cloud, the Rorschach test seem like a really cool thing to do. What you say about the different age groups and perception on the same thing to be different gets me thinking. What we find fun like reading or painting might not be fun to someone else, I think it might also have something to do with experience. Your blog is awesome by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love the way you put everything in great details. Reading this made me want to read more it's great! I like the way how you and your nephew were debating on how the cloud looked like it and how the others saw the cloud differently.Gave me a great image great post!

    ReplyDelete
  5. At first when you and your nephew were discussing if it was a duck or a rabbit, I was reminded of the famous optical illusion of both a duck and rabbit, but this was a much better comparison than I was expecting, truly wonderful. As in, it definitely makes me wonder. Do you think it's just our cognitive functions that make us think things differently, or also our experiences?

    ReplyDelete
  6. This blog is quite interesting to read and learn from. I really enjoyed the reflection or inference you've made about your relatives opinions. Voice in this post is very good, especially on the last paragraph, making your audience learn something valuable. I do look forward to reading more of your posts.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought it was interesting that all four of you saw different images in the clouds. The age difference is a definite possibility as to why you all saw something different. When I first saw the image you posted it reminded me of blackened lungs, like from smoking. You really gave your observation thought and turned it into a beautiful blog to read. You made great connections, great job.

    ReplyDelete